To do or not to do.
I grew up in the 1960’s, in a working class neighbourhood in a northern mining village. However, there was never any sense of my being limited by my background. If I was capable and clever, and I passed my examinations, the state-school system would deliver me to college and then on to university. The fact that my parents had little money didn’t matter. All of this was free, and the world was my oyster. I just had to want it and be willing to work for it.
Things changed however. I think it was in the 1980’s. We were dreaming crazy dreams in those days, speculating on the ballooning stock market and the housing market – even interest rates in humble saving accounts had hit 10%. We were all going to be rich. At 28, I had a warm, cosy vision of the future – retirement at 55, and the chance to persue my dreams without the inconvenience of having to earn a living any more. I could simply invest my way to freedom. The mantra of the 80’s was defintiely “more-more-more”.
Of course, it couldn’t last.
The 90’s came, a long slow train wreck of a decade: fewer jobs, making do, targets to meet, economy, efficiency, downsize, de-mean,… and a general sense of “less-less-less”. The only way to sustain your dreams was to flash the plastic, rack up scary levels of debt and pretend they didn’t exist.
I’d noticed a type of person becoming prominent in the 80’s, often parodied but curiously resilient: the so called yuppie type, the professional manager, the careerist. They could sell you anything, hypnotize you with their patter and their superior “interpersonal skills”. They could flim-flam you with their meaningless acronymn-speak, outwit you in meetings with a kind of verbal Kung-Fu and then be gone tomorrow before you realised they actually knew nothing at all. They were untouchable – forever moving on and up to the next level of their career. They’d jump company, jump ship, and never touch down for long enough to pick up any responsibility at all. Slippery as wet soap they were, but they also drove the best cars – the Beamers and the Porsches, while I was rattling around in an old Cortina. So they had to be doing something right. Right?
But what were they doing? Well, so far as I could tell these people had made a career out of doing nothing at all. They attended meetings, they facilitated meetings, they networked, and they delegated stuff. But they did nothing that you could point your finger at.
During the downsizing, de-meaning nineties, these non-doers became management consultants.They would hypnotize you into thinking you were incompetent, that you couldn’t manage your own affairs and you needed their thousand pounds a day expertise. They would flim-flam you with their freshly pressed management guru-speak, and their alarmingly nose-diving charts, then recommend a 10% year on year cut in the workforce, whilst offshoring any job that came down to the price of a pair of hands. Our loss was the far-east’s gain – and the gain of the non-doers of course.
If you were a “doer” you were basically in trouble from about 1988 – and you still are. By “doer”, I mean anyone who actually does something that they can call to mind at the end of the working day when their kids ask them, and reply in very simple terms: today I did this. I’m not just talking about people who work with their hands here – I’m talking about the designers, as well as the builders. But I’m also talking about the doctors and nurses, the firemen, the policemen, the soldiers, the sailors, the teachers, the farmers, the fishermen – people who do something for heaven’s sake!
If you ask a ten year old what they want to do when they grow up it’ll be a doing job.
What those ten year olds don’t yet know is that for every single doing job, there are ten non-doers standing on your shoulders, weighing you down. They also nail your feet to the floor and tie your hands behind your back, making up other stuff for you to do in order to measure you, to benchmark you,… to control you.
And the measurements become like laws, like statutes, because no-one wants to be seen to fail. No one wants a cross in the box against their name, when the Powerpoint slide goes up in front of the corporate deity. So the doing job becomes secondary to the accounting of what one is supposed to be doing. And while the non-doers strut and coo over their targets, they fail to notice the infrastructure over which they supposedly preside is actually falling down. It’s actually not working any more. The non-doers don’t do anything, and they don’t seem to like the idea of anyone else doing things either. But a Powerpoint presentation doesn’t put bread on the table – well not unless you’re a non-doer – in which case you can make a career out of it.
I’m fifty now – as near as makes no difference, and I know I won’t be retiring at 55 . That generation’s gone and good luck to them. I seem to be in it for the long term, sunk up to my neck and contemplating an end-game in some distant decade when all I can see there being left to do is sit in front of a Powerpoint presentation that’s telling us why we’re sitting in front of a Powerpoint presentation. Unless the non-doers decide I’m too old and find a way of tipping me onto the scrapper anyway.
Oh,… grow up, they tell me. The world has changed, it’s moved on. It’s fast, dynamic – no place for someone who wants to simply do things any more. It’s better this way, they tell me, this era of non-doing. But if I look at the world I cannot see any improvement in it, I mean in terms of the quality of life and the basic life-chances of the ordinary people of my country. I know the rich are proportionately much richer – but that’s not a measure of the richness of a society – more its moral poverty.
If I was born into a working class family now, the chances are I’d stay there. In the 60’s if you didn’t work it was because you were work shy. Now there are entire areas of my country that are economically inactive – we don’t even use the “unemployed” word any more – nowadays generation follow generation into the vacuum of state dependency. And if my children want to go to university I’ll have to spend what I’d once optimistically labelled my “retirement fund” in order to send them there. Student loans? No thanks. My kids aren’t starting out their lives being saddled with any more debt than they have to be.
Oh, to be sure, it’s a hard time to be a doer, because you’re surrounded by non-doers who are so far away from reality they have to hire sub-contractors to tie their shoelaces for them. And all they’ve got to say to us is why we can’t do something, or why they’re going to get someone else to it because our hands are just too damned expensive these days. And if you ask awkward questions about the cost of their non-doing, their posturing in one long meeting after another, their travel allowances, their hotel bills – well, that’s different somehow. Maybe it is but I’m too old to work it out, and too old to care any more.
A wise old bird once told me I should never admit to having any practical knowledge whatsoever because it has a way of holding you back. He was a cynical old curmudgeon, but I see his point. Still, for all of that I couldn’t be a non-doer. Could you?
What did you do today?
(apologies dear reader – it was a wierd and trying day)